Mas
10-02-2006, 08:12 PM
NEW YORK (MarketWatch) -- McAfee Inc. (MFE) Chief Executive George Samenuk said Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) is compromising the security of millions of computer users by backing away from years of technical cooperation with security-software makers.
The security-software maker reached out to reporters Monday and placed a full-page advertisement in the Financial Times newspaper charging Microsoft with anticompetitive behavior.
"Microsoft is using something out of their old play book in not collaborating with us," Samenuk said in an interview.
Microsoft disputed the notion that it is freezing out security companies or promoting its own security products at the expense of third-party players. And it charged that it is McAfee and Symantec Corp. (SYMC) that are trying to restrict competition.
Characterizing the changes as security enhancements, Adrien Robinson, a director in the Microsoft Security Technology Unit, said the software giant remains committed to working with security companies. "Microsoft needs to raise the bar in security," she said. "We know we can't do this alone."
McAfee and competitor Symantec have complained recently about changes made by Microsoft in how third-party security products must interact with the new version of the Windows operating system, Vista.
The companies say Microsoft is denying security-software makers access to the core of the new operating system, which is known as the "kernel," that they need to provide effective defenses against viruses and other attacks on Windows PCs, by far the main focus of malicious attackers.
"The new operating system, Vista, leaves the user, leaves the consumer, less safe than ever before," Samenuk said. Without kernel access, "our security (products) may not be as reliable as they have been for the last decade, and that hurts the consumers, and it hurts Microsoft."
Microsoft's Robinson said Microsoft simply is using a technology called PatchGuard to add tighter controls around the kernel and protect it from alteration and attack.
"In the past, we were able to leave the windows and doors unlocked," she said. "In the new world with the threats and malicious activities, Microsoft is needing to provide locks." Security companies and other parties, she added, will get "keys," or approved ways to access the kernel that will allow Microsoft to maintain its "security, reliability and integrity."
McAfee and Symantec also complain that Vista will direct computer users to a security console, dubbed Windows Security Center, that displays information about their PC's security status, rather than allowing security companies to supplant the Microsoft console with their own tools, as was allowed in the past.
"They have enabled their security to be the default solution and are not giving customers a choice of security systems," Samenuk said. He also said consumers could become confused if they get conflicting messages on their screens from Microsoft and their security provider.
Robinson said the console is simply an information service that kicks in when a computer user does not have adequate protection in place, and it does not replace security companies' tools or promote Microsoft products.
McAfee and Symantec are the ones who fear competition, she argued. Vista will allow 10 additional security companies to offer their products along with leaders Symantec and McAfee and Microsoft's own security product, OneCare.
"They believe that once they're on that machine, that customer is their customer," Robinson said. "What Windows Security Center has done is created a channel for other" independent software makers.
The security-software maker reached out to reporters Monday and placed a full-page advertisement in the Financial Times newspaper charging Microsoft with anticompetitive behavior.
"Microsoft is using something out of their old play book in not collaborating with us," Samenuk said in an interview.
Microsoft disputed the notion that it is freezing out security companies or promoting its own security products at the expense of third-party players. And it charged that it is McAfee and Symantec Corp. (SYMC) that are trying to restrict competition.
Characterizing the changes as security enhancements, Adrien Robinson, a director in the Microsoft Security Technology Unit, said the software giant remains committed to working with security companies. "Microsoft needs to raise the bar in security," she said. "We know we can't do this alone."
McAfee and competitor Symantec have complained recently about changes made by Microsoft in how third-party security products must interact with the new version of the Windows operating system, Vista.
The companies say Microsoft is denying security-software makers access to the core of the new operating system, which is known as the "kernel," that they need to provide effective defenses against viruses and other attacks on Windows PCs, by far the main focus of malicious attackers.
"The new operating system, Vista, leaves the user, leaves the consumer, less safe than ever before," Samenuk said. Without kernel access, "our security (products) may not be as reliable as they have been for the last decade, and that hurts the consumers, and it hurts Microsoft."
Microsoft's Robinson said Microsoft simply is using a technology called PatchGuard to add tighter controls around the kernel and protect it from alteration and attack.
"In the past, we were able to leave the windows and doors unlocked," she said. "In the new world with the threats and malicious activities, Microsoft is needing to provide locks." Security companies and other parties, she added, will get "keys," or approved ways to access the kernel that will allow Microsoft to maintain its "security, reliability and integrity."
McAfee and Symantec also complain that Vista will direct computer users to a security console, dubbed Windows Security Center, that displays information about their PC's security status, rather than allowing security companies to supplant the Microsoft console with their own tools, as was allowed in the past.
"They have enabled their security to be the default solution and are not giving customers a choice of security systems," Samenuk said. He also said consumers could become confused if they get conflicting messages on their screens from Microsoft and their security provider.
Robinson said the console is simply an information service that kicks in when a computer user does not have adequate protection in place, and it does not replace security companies' tools or promote Microsoft products.
McAfee and Symantec are the ones who fear competition, she argued. Vista will allow 10 additional security companies to offer their products along with leaders Symantec and McAfee and Microsoft's own security product, OneCare.
"They believe that once they're on that machine, that customer is their customer," Robinson said. "What Windows Security Center has done is created a channel for other" independent software makers.